Two young mathematicians examine one (or two?) functions once again.
- Devyn
- Riley, I have another pressing question.
- Riley
- Sure, what is it?
- Devyn
- Think about the function
- Riley
- Okay. What about it?
- Devyn
- Is this function equal to ?
- Riley
- Well if I plot them with my calculator, they look the same.
- Devyn
- I know! But remember when we realized before that and are not the same function? I think this could be a similar situation.
- Riley
- Okay, let’s check. I suppose I could write
- Devyn
- Right! But what about when ? In this case,
- Riley
- Okay, is undefined because we cannot divide by zero. Hmm...
Suppose and are functions but the domain of is different from the domain of .
Could it be that and are actually the same function?
yes no
The domain of a function is part of the ‘‘data’’ of the function. A function is not a
rule for transforming the input to the output, but rather the relationship between a
specified collection of inputs (the domain) and possible outputs (the range).
If you simplify a function and realize the simplified form is , is it possible that and
have different domains and are therefore different functions?
yes no
When simplifying functions, you have to be careful because sometimes the simplified
form of a function does not have the same domain as the original function. In this
case, the two functions are not actually equal! We will investigate this further in the
next card.