We summarize the properties of the determinant that we already proved, and prove that a matrix is singular if and only if its determinant is zero, the determinant of a product is the product of the determinants, and the determinant of the transpose is equal to the determinant of the matrix.

DET-0040: Properties of the Determinant

Summary of Results

We first defined the determinant of a matrix using cofactor expansion along the first row. (Definition def:toprowexpansion of DET-0010) We then introduced an alternative definition in terms of cofactor expansion along the first column and proved that the two definitions are equivalent. (Definition def:firstcolexpansion1 of DET-0020) We also proved the following simple but useful results:

(a)
The determinant of the identity matrix is equal to 1. (Lemma lemma:detofid)
(b)
If a matrix contains a row of zeros, then its determinant is equal to 0. (Lemma lemma:det0lemma)
(c)
If two rows of a matrix are the same, then the determinant of the matrix is equal to 0. (Lemma lemma:det0lemma)
(d)
If one row of a matrix is a scalar multiple of another row, then the determinant of the matrix is equal to 0. (Lemma lemma:det0lemma)

We also found that elementary row operations affect the determinant as follows:

(a)
If is obtained from by interchanging two different rows, then
(b)
If is obtained from by multiplying one of the rows of by a non-zero constant . Then
(c)
If is obtained from by adding a multiple of one row of to another row, then

(Theorem th:elemrowopsanddet of DET-0030)

In this module we will prove the following important results:

(a)
A square matrix is singular if and only if its determinant is equal to 0.
(b)
The determinant of a product is the product of the determinants.
(c)
The determinant of the transpose is equal to the determinant of the matrix.

To get us started, we need the following lemma.

Proof
Recall that if is obtained from using an elementary row operation, then the same elementary row operation carries to . There are three types of elementary row operations and three types of elementary matrices, so we will have to consider three cases.

Case 1. Suppose is obtained from by interchanging two rows, then so

Case 2. Suppose is obtained from by multiplying one of the rows of by a non-zero constant , then so

Case 3. Suppose is obtained from by adding a scalar multiple of one row to another row, then so

Invertibility and the Determinant

Recall that we first introduced determinants in the context of invertibility of matrices. Specifically, we found that is invertible if and only if . (A logically equivalent statement is: is singular if and only if .) We are now in the position to prove this result for all square matrices.

Proof
Let be a square matrix. To determine whether is singular we need to find . In MAT-0060 we found that there exist elementary matrices such that so By repeated application of Lemma lemma:detelemproduct, we find that Suppose that is singular, then . But then contains a row of zeros, and . (Lemma lemma:det0lemma) Since determinants of elementary matrices are non-zero, we conclude that .

Conversely, suppose , then But then , so is singular.

Determinant of a Product

Proof
Suppose is invertible, then can be written as a product of elementary matrices. (Theorem th:elemmatrices of MAT-0060) Then, by repeated application of Lemma lemma:detelemproduct, we get

Now suppose that is not invertible. Then is also not invertible. So, and . Thus .

The following theorem is a nice consequence of Theorem th:detofproduct. We leave the proof to the reader. (Practice Problem prob:proofdetofinverse)

Determinant of the Transpose

In Practice Problem prob:dettranspose of DET-0020 you proved that . Your proof most likely relied on the fact that cofactor expansion along the first row produces the same result as cofactor expansion along the first column. (Theorem th:rowcolexpequivalence). We will now take another look at this result and prove it without the assumption that the two cofactor expansions produce the same outcome.

In this problem we will take a look at the determinants of transposes of elementary matrices. Recall that an elementary matrix is obtained from the identity matrix by means of one elementary row operation. Consider the following examples of elementary matrices. On your own, write out the transpose of each matrix. You should observe that and .

Now consider Clearly , but what is really important is that is also an elementary matrix. While was obtained from the identity by adding 4 times the third row to the first row, was obtained from the identity by adding 4 times the first row to the third row. By Theorem th:elemrowopsanddetitem:addmultotherrowdet of DET-0030, we know that .

So, for all three matrices we have .

We can generalize our observations in Exploration init:detoftranspose as follows:

(a)
If is an elementary matrix obtained from the identity by switching of two rows, then .
(b)
If is an elementary matrix obtained from the identity by multiplying one row by a non-zero constant, then .
(c)
If is an elementary matrix obtained from the identity by adding a multiple of one row to another row, then .

We will now combine the three parts of our generalization into a lemma.

Proof
We will need to consider three cases.

Case 1. Suppose is obtained from the identity by switching rows and . Then is the same as the identity matrix, except that and entries of are zero, and has a 1 in and spots. When the transpose is taken, 1’s and 0’s along the diagonal stay in place, while the -entry becomes the -entry and the -entry becomes the -entry. This shows that , and .

Case 2. Suppose is obtained from the identity by multiplying one of the rows by a non-zero constant. Observe that is a diagonal matrix, so and .

Case 3. Suppose is obtained from the identity by adding a times row to row . Then is the same as the identity matrix, except that the -entry of is . If we take the transpose of , then will become the -entry of the transpose. This means that can be obtained from the identity by adding times row to row . This means that .

We are now ready to prove the main result of this section.

Proof
Suppose that is singular, then is also singular. (Theorem th:invprop of MAT-0050 and Theorem th:transposeproperties of MAT-0025) Thus, .

Suppose is nonsingular. Then is can be written as a product of elementary matrices (Theorem th:elemmatrices of MAT-0060) By Theorem th:transposeproperties of MAT-0025 By Lemma lemma:detofelementarymat, for .

Practice Problems

Without doing written computations, determine whether the given matrix is singular.
is singular is nonsingular
is singular is nonsingular
Show that all matrices of the form are singular.
Find values of for which the given matrix is singular. List values of in an increasing order.

Answer:

Suppose and are matrices such that and . Find each of the following.
Prove or give a counterexample.
Prove Theorem th:detofinverse.
Suppose is an invertible matrix such that Find if we know that .

Answer: